A method validated on its own results proves nothing. Ours is measured against published crystal structures and published experimental values, so anyone can pull the same references and check the arithmetic.
Independent benchmark
Does this just repeat what SPR already tells you?
It does not, and we checked. Taking three ternary complex structures published by an outside group, we computed our membrane compatibility metric for compounds whose cooperativity that same group had measured by SPR. Two of them differ 34-fold in cooperativity — α = 143 against α = 4.2 — and our metric could not tell them apart. The gap between the two values falls well inside the measurement uncertainty we later quantified, ±6.6 percentage points.
So the quantity we measure is not one the binding experiment already reports. It is orthogonal information, not a slower route to a number you can get from SPR.
It is also not a potency predictor — in that series, cooperativity dominated the outcome. Our contribution sits upstream of it: ruling out the geometries a membrane will not permit, before anyone commits to synthesis.
A published ternary complex, reproducedFrom crystallographic coordinates, 100 ns of unrestrained dynamics kept every interaction the structure paper identifies. The defining salt bridge held in every frame, at a mean distance matching the crystallographic value.
Ligand parameters with no hand correctionAcross 298–1,486 Da, including degraders with more than twenty rotatable bonds. No missing parameters, no substituted analogies.
Bilayer properties against measurementThickness within 0.2% of the scattering value, and the order parameter profile reproduced along both acyl chains — including the dip at the site of unsaturation.
Orientation behaviour against the literatureReproduced. Published studies reached those states with microseconds of sampling; ours arrived within hundreds of nanoseconds. One of the states appears in every replica we have run; the other does not, and we say so rather than average them together.
Two orientations carried in parallelBoth membrane states are constructed from the same procedure and equilibrated under the same protocol, so the comparison between them rests on the orientation and not on how each was assembled.
Controls before rankingsWhere a target has published measurements, we run a control set alongside the candidates and measure the resolution of the method before we rank anything. Where no such set exists, we do not produce a ranking. We have discarded rankings made without one.
What survives more samplingExtending our trajectories by a factor of three cut the absolute compatibility values by as much as half. The ordering of compounds did not change, and neither did which pairs the method cannot separate. We report rankings and separability rather than absolute values, because those are what held.